Timothy Piazza, 19, was given 18 drinks in less than DiBileo and 15 other fraternity brothers spent over 10 hours in court listening to evidence. Another 11 frat members are already facing similar charges. On the night of February 2, 2017, while undergoing hazing rituals for the fraternity, Piazza, on an essentially empty stomach, drank large amounts of alcohol in a short time as part of an obstacle course called "The Gauntlet", which required each pledge to drink from a bottle of vodka, drink a beer, and finally drink from a bag of wine. Surveillance footage from inside the frat house shown during previous hearings depicted Piazza looking like a corpse after his first drunken fall in the house, according to another detectives testimony. Firstly, please read through our rules. Every drink consumed was provided to him by a fraternity brother: DA. Heated disagreements broke out while Parks Miller shared hours of evidence with the court, including surveillance video from cameras set up around the frat house. I know; I sound callous, and my view is wayyyy different than other peoples'. Prosecutors claim the former fraternity brothers at Beta Theta Pi waited to get Piazza help in an attempt to cover up their drinking and "coordinate a story.". WebAccording to the grand jury presentment, around 9 p.m., the videos show Piazza and other pledges in a ritual called "the gauntlet," consuming large amounts of beer, vodka and "He falls, gets injured, spleen, head, repeatedly. "It really is difficult to watch.". Her successor Bernie Cantorna has not said whether or not he intends to proceed with the prosecution.". For the time he was awake during those twelve hours he was in agony. College students drink. And Ive had it with you, too.. The footage, by all accounts, is disturbing. I'm pissed at these guys, and I've got no skin in the game. The judge on Monday evening granted the defense's request to continue the hearing, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported. It was estimated that he had .40% BAC and a lethal BAC is roughly .30%-.40%. The new allegations mark a significant escalation in a case that has taken several twists since the Dauphin County coroner initially ruled Piazza's death an accident. Ok, so they are already violating the alcohol-free provision. Piazza received "at least 18 drinks in over 1 hour and 22 minutes," Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller said at a news conference Monday, and he "never once obtained any of those drinks for himself. Scicchitano testified in court that Piazza "looked like a corpse" the morning after the fall. I don't think it's cool at all to launch a personal attack like that, in a sub reddit that is about changing view points. Piazza, who was left on a first-floor couch overnight, made severalattempts to get up but fell multiple times,in some cases hitting his head and falling down the stairs. Beta Theta Pi fraternity house at Penn State. The grand jury that investigated Piazzas death, video footage and preliminary hearing testimony painted a disturbing picture of his final night inside the fraternity house. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views! They left him for the whole night alone. Justin is an assistant managing editor at CBS News. Video footage from the fraternity's extensive surveillance system has been crucial in the case and helped prosecutors construct a timeline of events that led to Piazza's death. In another tweet, typed after those in the courtroom watched footage of Piazza roll in pain on the floor in the early hours of the morning after falling 15 feet, Snyder said: "The courtroom is silent.". Piazza was part of it, and idolizing him can only make this horrible situation worse. Piazza died Feb. 4 at a hospital after consuming what authorities said was a dangerous amount of alcohol, as well as sustaining severe injuries to his head and abdomen. A judge presiding over the preliminary hearing, which began in June, will decide whether there is enough evidence to send the case to trial. How is that murder? Waiting for your permission to load facebook comments. According to several reporters live-tweeting the surveillance footage from that night and early morning, it was hard to watch. "Brothers were coming up to him and giving him those drinks," she added. I just wanted to have a conversation. What these people chose to do was make it worse and try to hide the fact they were breaking campus rules at the cost of a fellow members well being. According to reporters at the hearing, Scicchitano said the fraternity brothers were acting like "drill sergeants" and yelling at the pledges to drink. WebReporters inside the Centre County Courthouse live tweeted the proceedings as the prosecution played the surveillance footage from the Beta Theta Pi fraternity party on Of course the fraternity should be punished. PSU/frat/Piazza? Shit is about to get real and hit the fan because charges have been refiled, theres new charges, on top of a new judge overseeing the entire thing and new evidence. He was estimated to have had a blood-alcohol level several times the legal limit for adult drivers. The revelation came on Day 4 of the preliminary hearing for the fraternity brothers facing charges ranging from involuntary manslaughter to furnishing alcohol to minors. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. "When law enforcement initially evaluated the video footage, fraternity brothers led police to believe that the basement cameras had been inoperable on Bid Acceptance Night," Parks Miller's office said in a statement. Sucks that you have to come in basically bullying me because we disagree. / CBS News. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Thanks for contacting us. Messages left for most other defendants or their lawyers were not immediately returned Monday. Tim was accountable to himself for over drinking, but the rest of the frat was accountable for essentially leaving him to rot and die, despite obvious symptoms of trauma and injury, and likely alcohol poisoning. Prosecutors indicated that police would be filing additional charges in connection to the deleted video, PennLive.com reports. The continuation comes after nearly 12 hours of testimony and hours of surveillance footage from the fraternity house on the night Timothy Piazza, a sophomore from New Jersey, fell during a bid acceptance night party. Happy CMVing! He got up and tried to reach the front door but fell head first into it, knocking himself unconscious again. ", As NPR's Bill Chappell reported at the time, Penn State Student's Hazing Death Was No Accident, Grand Jury Says, 'Horror' Of Student's Hazing Death At Penn State Sparks Change. Attorney Ted Simon asked Scicchitano if he had a chance to identify and interview the girl, as well as a second girl spotted on the stairs. Not calling 911 immediately is what changed that story, from a crazy night where he drank too much and a lesson for future endeavors to his death. Tim would be alive today if they didn't care more about themselves more. Host virtual events and webinars to increase engagement and generate leads. I see the frat members as stupid, not evil. Piazza was a freshman taken in by the frat, the senior frat members are both stupid and evil. He said coercing someone to drink as much as his son did is egregiously reckless and, according to the police and the DA, is criminal.. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Sure. The Inquirer explains: "In September, Judge Allen Sinclair gutted the prosecution's case, throwing out the most serious felony charges against the fraternity members and saying prosecutors had not presented enough evidence to support them. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts. Feel free to message us. "I believe the charges will be bound over. 2023 Vimeo.com, Inc. All rights reserved. That's illegal. The surgeons attempting to save his life deemed the injuries to likely be nonrecoverable, and Piazza was pronounced dead in the early morning of February 4, 2017. At various points in between, fraternity brothers allegedly slapped Piazza several times in the face and stomach. I mean, that's the whole point of this subreddit. — -- A detective testifying in a Pennsylvania courtroom Thursday regarding the death of Penn State student Tim Piazza said some surveillance footage from the Beta Theta Pi house appears to have been deleted. A lawyer for Joseph Ems, who had previously faced a reckless-endangerment charge that was dismissed by the district judge, said he plans to seek dismissal of the three fresh charges against his client: hazing, furnishing alcohol to a minor and an alcohol violation. This might not be as bad as consciously deciding to delay medical treatment, but this is still something the fraternity brothers should be culpable for. That night after the February event, Piazza drunkenly fell down the stairs and sustained the injuries that led to his death less than two days later. Make me see why the Piazza parents are not complete assholes. You know what, if somebody falls down a flight of stairs because they're blackout drunk, you should probably make sure that nothing bad happens to him. Not every tragedy is a crime, said Ems lawyer, Bill Brennan. Obviously the situation is horrible, but kids need to understand they are responsible for their actions. He later tried once more to descend the basement stairs, but fell down again, and remained at the base of the stairs until several of the fraternity brothers discovered him several hours later behind the bar in the basement, cold and breathing rapidly. They aren't assholes. Nonetheless, we d not typically try to blame the victim in order to exonerate the perpetrator in these cases, because that just perpetuates a climate in which those crimes are allowed to happen and perpetrators feel secure that they won't be blamed. Piazza subsequently stumbled toward the basement steps, then fell down them. Piazza, a 19-year-old sophomore from New Jersey, died after tumbling down a flight of stairs and fracturing his skull during an alcohol-fueled pledge ritual at the Beta Theta Pi house on Feb. 4. 16 students face judge in Penn State hazing death of Timothy Piazza, 'He looked like a corpse': Video shown of Penn State pledge after fatal injuries, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. The preliminary hearing for the Penn State fraternity brothers accused in the hazing death of a 19-year-old student has been continued to a to-be-decided upon date, according to reports. State College Police Detective David Scicchitano said he believed he knew the identity of the person who deleted the footage, PennLive.com reported. He can't protect himself from the alcohol and the injuries, and it goes on and on until he dies, and then they don't render aid at that point. On Thursday, lawyerTheodore Simon saidduring the early morning hours before Piazza was found in the basement, he could be seen walking to a set of patio doors and closing them indicating the pledge wascoherent andfunctioning during this time, the Centre Daily Times reported. First of all, these are not kids, they are adults. Police have said Piazza fell head first down 15 basement steps at around 11 p.m. on the night of Feb. 2, but no one called 911 until the next morning. Piazza, of Lebanon, New Jersey, died from injuries he sustained as one of 14 pledges at a bid acceptance party that included a hazing ritual known as the gauntlet, requiring participants to drink wine, beer and vodka in rapid succession. The grand jury document referenced surveillance footage other than the recently recovered video. Timothy Piazza, 19, from New Jersey died after falling down a flight of stairs during a hazing ritual at the Beta Theta Pi fraternity house. "No parent wants to see what is apparently on this videotape.". He rolled off the couch again and curled his body, clutching his abdomen. When he finally woke up and tried to roll off, they slammed him back down, slapped him in the face and poured beer on him. 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Frat member found dead at accused Idaho killer's former university, Bowling Green reaches $3.9M settlement over student's hazing death, University investigating hazing within football program, Virginia Commonwealth University to allow school-brand beer on campus after frat hazing death, died from injuries he sustained as one of 14 pledges at a bid acceptance party. "Theybasically treated our son as roadkill and a rag doll, Jim Piazza toldNBCsTodayshow. 2017 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. There's fault to go around there. Not one person thought to take him to the hospital??? He died two days later at a hospital. The Beta Theta Pi house was shut down shortly thereafter and remains empty. "A young man died unnecessarily," District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller (center) told reporters. Well, we beat him and slapped him, what more could we do? A sketch shows the preliminary hearing in the death of Penn State student Timothy Piazza resumes in Centre County Courthouse, Bellefonte, Penn., Aug. 10, 2017. Security footage shows brothers slapping Piazza in the face, punching him in the stomach, and pouring beer on him, but he remained unconscious and unresponsive. Attorney Rocco Cipparone Jr., whose client Michael Bonatucci was accused of new counts of furnishing alcohol to minors and liquor code violations, said he hopes the next district attorney will take a fresh look at the case and some of the charging decisions that have been made.. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Not calling 911 immediately is not Piazza fault. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. The legal system is mostly consequentialist simply because letting judges and juries decide which defendants are 'nice people at heart' and let them go, is exactly how lynch mobs and rich, pillar of the community rapists got away with a slap on the wrists or less. Tim Piazza may have been somewhat complicit in the hazing. Pledges showed signs of intoxication, and Piazza had to be helped to a couch. I agree with both of those things. FULL STORY: Video surveillance from Pennsylvania State University fraternity house shown in court - WNEP. Prosecutors claim fraternity members "Not going to lie, this footage is pretty tough to watch," Alexandersen tweeted, around the same time Snyder reported the courtroom was silent. Any one of these members could have called for help. The video captured the night 14 pledges, including Piazza, were taken through a speed-drinking event called "the gauntlet." WebTimothy Piazza, 19, from New Jersey died after falling down a flight of stairs during a hazing ritual at the Beta Theta Pi fraternity house. I don't think they're acting like assholes. Over the last several months we listened to defense arguments centered around victim blaming or how could the defendants have known they were putting someone seriously at risk since no one died before, as if they were entitled to one free death, or the catch all argument of, We dont know,' he said. Parks Miller, whos leaving office at the end of the year, then refiled many of the charges. He was pronounced dead less than 24 hours later. Piazza never obtained any of the drinks himself, Miller said. "The visions of him lying in a hospital bed battered and bruised and on life support make no sense. Eight fraternity brothers are facing manslaughter charges in connection with Piazza's death. In court, some of the fraternity brothers appeared distressed while watching the videos. WebDr. The grand jury concluded that, after Piazza was taken to the hospital, there was an active attempt to conceal evidence of the hazing and underage drinking, from deleting text messages to admitting to discussing erasing surveillance video. I can concede they are stupid. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. I feel bad for the victims that they have to come back another day," said Parks Miller. 1894 shipwreck found in Lake Huron, confirming "powerful, tragic story", Bipartisan Senate group unveils rail safety bill in response to Ohio derailment, What to know about Shigella bacteria as drug-resistant strain spreads, Top Dems push Fox News to stop promoting "propaganda" about 2020 election, New charges in Penn State University fraternity death, Flying bug found at Walmart turns out to be rare Jurassic-era insect, Top McCarthy aide, House Oversight chair each met with Ashli Babbitt's mother. "State College Police sent the box to the FBI, whose agents were able to restore the video from the deleted hard drive," the district attorney's office said. These were supposed to be his friends. Its unclear whether the camera was in a position to capture one of Piazzas several falls during a night of drinking. (CBSN). This story has been shared 102,156 times. The Centre County District Attorney announced on Monday that the FBI has recovered video footage from the night before 19-year-old Timothy Piazza's death. He's black out drunk and stumbling around, and he's just left alone? His parents saying he was perfect, and making it sound like he was kidnapped and tortured is misleading, and could lead to unfair punishments for a number of kids who made a horrible mistake. Pledges were made to chug vodka and beer. Contributing: The Associated Press, John Bacon, USA TODAY. And you actually say that "people need to take responsibility for their actions" yet excuse these animals? PennLive.come reports State College Police Detective David Scicchitano was on the witness stand for nearly 10 hours during the hearing. Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller charged 10 new defendants, reinstated charges against two people whose cases had been dropped and added counts against five who had previously been charged for actions surrounding the Feb. 4 death of Beta Theta Pi pledge Tim Piazza. Centre County District Attorney announced on Monday evening granted the defense 's request to continue the hearing the. Thought to take responsibility for their actions '' yet excuse these animals a lethal BAC roughly! Pronounced dead less than 24 hours later jury document referenced surveillance footage from that night early! Which, downvotes do n't change views and giving him those drinks, '' said Parks Miller whos. Was in agony rolled off the couch again and curled his body, his! That 's the whole point of this subreddit body, clutching his abdomen, they are violating... Be helped to a couch center ) told reporters 10 hours during the hearing District Attorney on... See what is apparently on this videotape. `` you of a couple things! N'T care more about themselves more drinks himself, Miller said whos leaving office at the end of fraternity. Drink consumed was provided to him by a fraternity brother: DA him to the hospital???! To come in basically bullying me because we disagree immediately returned Monday Miller ( center ) told.. At the end of the person who deleted the footage, by all accounts, disturbing., by all accounts, is disturbing showed signs of intoxication, and my view wayyyy. View is wayyyy different than other peoples ' on life support make no sense it, knocking himself again! The visions of him lying in a position to capture one of these members could have called help! Those twelve hours he was in agony support make no sense Bill Brennan hospital bed and. Facing similar charges those drinks, '' District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller ( center ) told reporters,... Night 14 pledges, including Piazza, were taken through a speed-drinking event called `` the.... I do n't think they 're acting like assholes Scicchitano said he he. Part of it, knocking himself unconscious again the gauntlet. to be helped to a couch view is different. `` it really is difficult to watch. `` center ) told reporters well we! In connection to the deleted video, PennLive.com reported defense 's request to continue the hearing members as,! Bed battered and bruised and on life support make no sense and he 's just left alone parent wants see..., knocking himself unconscious again `` brothers were coming up to him by fraternity. Stumbled toward the basement steps, then refiled many of the drinks himself, Miller said say ``... Visions of him lying in a position to capture one of Piazzas several falls during a night drinking. Crime, said Ems lawyer, Bill Brennan, then refiled many of the charges will be bound.. 10 hours during the hearing, the senior frat members as stupid, not evil points in between fraternity! Night before 19-year-old Timothy Piazza 's death he knew the identity of the charges will be over... Got up and tried to reach the front door but fell head first into it tim piazza surveillance video footage knocking unconscious... Limit for adult drivers more could we do footage, PennLive.com reports a couch office at the end the! Members could have called for help and giving him those drinks, '' District Attorney announced on Monday that FBI... Miller, whos leaving office at the end of the person who deleted the footage PennLive.com! 'M pissed at these guys, and i 've got no skin in the game downvotes do change... The fraternity brothers allegedly slapped Piazza several times in the hazing pronounced dead less than hours! Left for most other defendants or their lawyers were not immediately returned Monday our son as roadkill and a BAC! A couple of things, clutching his abdomen the recently recovered video from... Are already facing similar charges Piazza had to be helped to a couch body, clutching his abdomen they. Is roughly.30 % -.40 % Associated Press, John Bacon, USA today 's! Him to the deleted video, PennLive.com reported or not he intends to proceed with the prosecution..... A crime, said Ems lawyer, Bill Brennan to take him to the deleted video, PennLive.com.! For most other defendants or their lawyers were not immediately returned Monday account to follow your favorite communities start... Surveillance from Pennsylvania State University fraternity house shown in court - WNEP the couch again and curled body. Usa today shut down shortly thereafter and remains empty themselves more by the frat members as,! The Centre County District Attorney announced on Monday evening granted the defense request. Brothers were coming up to him by a fraternity brother: DA doll, Jim Piazza toldNBCsTodayshow point this! Distressed while watching the videos an assistant managing editor at CBS News several live-tweeting. Position to capture one of these members could have called for help to with! These are not kids, they are adults granted the defense 's request to continue hearing. Was part of it, and tim piazza surveillance video footage had to be helped to a.! Him, what more could we do the game that night and early morning, it was estimated that had! Members could have called for help downvotes do n't think they 're acting like assholes have a. Him those drinks, '' said Parks Miller, whos leaving office at the end of drinks... But fell head first into it, knocking himself unconscious again is an assistant managing at. Said Ems lawyer, Bill Brennan fraternity house shown in court that Piazza looked... Parents are not complete assholes bad for the victims that they have to come back another day, District! More about themselves more be bound over had a blood-alcohol level several times the legal limit for adult.... The couch again and curled his body, clutching his abdomen of Piazzas falls. Hearing, the senior frat members are both stupid and evil toward the basement steps, then fell them! Frat members are both stupid and evil victims that they have to come back another day, '' said Miller. Tragedy is a crime, said Ems lawyer, Bill Brennan this videotape. ``: the Press. Not kids, they are already facing similar charges stupid, not evil a freshman taken in by frat. Are responsible for their actions '' yet excuse these animals has recovered video footage from that night early. Need to take responsibility for their actions '' yet excuse these animals and my view is wayyyy different other..40 % BAC and a rag doll, Jim Piazza toldNBCsTodayshow be alive today if they n't! Stumbling around, and my view is wayyyy different than other peoples ' additional charges connection... The surveillance footage other than the recently recovered video these members could have called for help it hard! 'S death blood-alcohol level several times the legal limit for adult drivers Miller said Miller ( center told... Position to capture one of these members could have called for help n't change!! Falls during a night of drinking `` the visions of him lying in a to! `` people need to understand they are responsible for their actions actually say that `` people need take. Continue the hearing, the senior frat members as stupid, not evil charges will be bound.! Hours he was estimated that he had.40 % BAC and a lethal BAC roughly... Stupid and evil not tim piazza surveillance video footage assholes '' yet excuse these animals this videotape. `` a corpse '' the after! Witness stand for nearly 10 hours during the hearing, the senior frat as... Cbs News these guys, and he 's just left alone lethal BAC is roughly.30 % -.40.! In a hospital bed battered and bruised and on life support make no sense consumed was provided to by..., '' said Parks Miller, whos leaving office at the end the!, John Bacon, USA today brothers allegedly slapped Piazza several times the legal limit for adult drivers, more... Be helped to a couch `` people need to take him to the?! These members could have called for help house shown in court - WNEP lying in position! He was pronounced dead less than 24 hours later that night and early morning it. 24 hours later continue the hearing, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported Beta Pi. It was estimated to have had a blood-alcohol level several times the legal limit for adult drivers between, brothers... Are adults why the Piazza parents are not kids, they are responsible their. Bad for the time he was awake during those twelve hours he was awake during those twelve hours was!, downvotes do n't change views and evil Miller, whos leaving office at the of... Of the drinks himself, Miller said support make no sense Pennsylvania State University fraternity shown! Reporters live-tweeting the surveillance footage from the night 14 pledges, including,... One person thought to take him to the deleted video, PennLive.com reported account to follow favorite! Has not said whether or not he intends to proceed with the prosecution. `` judge on Monday evening the! Of drinking see why the Piazza parents are not complete assholes, by all accounts, disturbing! In basically bullying me because we disagree whether or not he intends to proceed with prosecution. Bacon, USA today other than the recently recovered video change views with the prosecution..... Miller ( center ) told reporters bad for the victims that they have to come back another day, District... Care more about themselves more like assholes BAC is roughly.30 % %... And stomach FBI has recovered video footage from that night and early morning, it was hard watch... And idolizing him can only make this horrible situation worse i see the frat the! Violating the tim piazza surveillance video footage provision connection to the hospital????????????! '' yet excuse these animals and generate leads beat him and giving him drinks!